Menu of Bed-Stuy Fish Fry in Brooklyn, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Bed-Stuy Fish Fry, located at 940 Fulton St, Brooklyn, stands out as a beacon of soulful seafood and comfort food. This restaurant, known for its authentic soul food dishes, offers a menu rich with flavors that resonate deeply with both traditional and modern palates. The seafood here is more than just a meal; it’s an experience crafted to satisfy cravings for hearty, well-seasoned food.

The menu highlights deliver on promise—particularly the Salmon with Mac & Cheese and Steamed Veggies, which balances the richness of the fish with creamy macaroni and fresh greens. The Chicken Dinner Platter with Mac & Cheese and Mashed Potatoes is another standout, showcasing generous portions and classic southern sides that feel like home. Their Grilled Salmon coupled with Collard Greens and Macaroni and Cheese is savory, perfectly cooked, and complemented by well-seasoned greens, reflecting the soulful spirit of the South.

Seafood lovers will appreciate the Catfish Dinner and the iconic Whiting Fish and Chips—crisp, tender, and paired with excellent tartar and ketchup sauces that enhance the flavors without overpowering them. The Salmon Sandwich offers a casual yet satisfying take on a beloved staple, making it an excellent choice for a quick, flavorful bite.

Side dishes deserve their own praise. The Mac & Cheese is frequently highlighted by patrons as an “everything” dish—comforting with a luscious, gooey texture that pulls just right. Customers consistently hail the French fries and seasoned sides like yams and collard greens for their authentic taste and home-style preparation. The potato salad and cabbage complement the entrees with balance, though the cabbage can vary in consistency, sometimes slipping on seasoning.

Desserts here are a sweet finale. The Peach Cobbler is a must-try—warm, fruity, and perfectly spiced. Alongside that, the German Chocolate Cake, Red Velvet, and Banana Pudding each are served in generous portions and embody classic Southern dessert traditions, all reasonably priced at $5.

Bed-Stuy Fish Fry caters to all ages, with a well-rounded kids menu and a salad bar that adds freshness and variety to the experience. The restaurant operates as a to-go spot, which means the focus is squarely on great food, delivered promptly and consistently.

What resonates most is the authentic soul in every dish—the expertly seasoned jerk chicken, the pull of the mac and cheese, the fresh, tender grilled shrimp, and the generous portions that honor tradition. Customer feedback points to an evolution in service courtesy, enhancing the overall dining experience despite the absence of on-site seating.

In summary, Bed-Stuy Fish Fry is a gem for those chasing soulful seafood and Southern comfort classics in Brooklyn. Its menu embodies rich flavors, hearty portions, and a commitment to quality that keeps locals and visitors coming back for more.